Castel Volturno, political controversy erupts after calls for the Pineta Grande owner's conviction.

Castel Volturno – The request for a five-year prison sentence filed by the Santa Maria Capua Vetere Public Prosecutor's Office against Vincenzo Schiavone, a well-known private healthcare entrepreneur and owner of the Pineta Grande Hospital in Castel Volturno, brings into the spotlight not only one of the most painful legal cases of recent years, but also the relationship between the leaders of the Campania healthcare system and those who influenced its decisions and investments.

A topic that intertwines justice and politics. Just days after his official appointment by the Court of Naples, the new president of the Campania Region, Roberto Fico, reiterated his priority of strengthening public healthcare. This stance, in light of the prosecutor's office's requests, is prompting many observers to reflect on healthcare policies and the significant investments made in recent years by former governor Vincenzo De Luca specifically in the Domitian healthcare system.

The prosecutors' closing statement

At the heart of the closing statement by public prosecutors Giacomo Urbano and Gerardina Cozzolino, delivered this morning in court, is the charge of ideological forgery: according to the prosecution, Schiavone orchestrated the falsification of the medical records of Francesca Oliva, the 29-year-old from Gricignano d'Aversa who died in May 2014 from fulminant sepsis after giving birth to triplets.

A tragedy that profoundly shocked public opinion: two of the babies, a boy and a girl, also died along with the young mother; only the third child survived. Nearly twelve years later, however, the judiciary's attention is focused on what happened after that tragic death, within the walls of the clinic.

The requests for conviction

The Prosecutor's Office did not seek a conviction only for the owner of Pineta Grande. Severe sentences were also requested for the three doctors charged with complicity in the forgery: 3 years and 6 months for Gabriele Vallefuoco and Giuseppe Delle Donne, and 3 years for Stefano Palmieri.

A rigorous line, also supported by the civil plaintiff. Attorney Raffaele Costanzo, representing Francesca Oliva's family, supported the prosecution's case, demanding justice for a family that has been waiting for answers for over a decade.

The antibiotic was never administered

The heart of the trial revolves around what investigators are calling a veritable "documentary makeover." According to the prosecution, the medical records were altered after the patient's death to build a defense after the fact.

Specifically, the administration of a broad-spectrum antibiotic was reportedly noted, which, according to the investigation, was never actually administered. At the same time, crucial references to the woman's progressive deterioration in general condition in the hours preceding her collapse were removed.

The judicial process

The forgery trial is an offshoot of the main manslaughter case, which concluded in October 2021 with the acquittal of 14 doctors from the Pineta Grande hospital and the Giugliano hospital, from which the woman had been transferred.

In that ruling, the court presided over by Roberta Carotenuto held the victim's trusted gynecologist, Sabatino Russo, responsible for the crime. He died in 2017 and is therefore no longer liable for prosecution.

Although direct medical liability has been dismissed, the possibility of a misdirected investigation remains, and now the healthcare facility's top management is being charged. The case against two of the clinic's IT technicians, Gianluca Salvatore Russo and Giorgio Conte, has been dismissed due to a failure to notify the case.

The trial will resume on February 23rd, when the defense will deliver closing arguments. The verdict will then be handed down, shedding definitive light on one of the most controversial issues in Campania's healthcare system.