Naples - Fourteen minutes that weigh like a millstone in the investigation into the death of little Domenico, two years and four months old, who died after a heart transplant performed on December 23rd at Monaldi Hospital.
According to the extracorporeal circulation (ECC) report, the so-called "no-way back point"—the moment at which the patient's heart is definitively cut off from circulation by aortic clamping—was passed at 2:18 PM. The new organ, however, did not arrive in the operating room until 2:30 PM.
Francesco Petruzzi, the parents' lawyer, claims this after examining the medical records, which were initially thought to be missing and later found. "Given the location of the card," the lawyer explains, "it emerges that Domenico's heart was disconnected from his body before the donated organ arrived."
For the family, this time gap would be proof that the child was deprived of his heart too early, making the implantation of the replacement organ inevitable even if damaged.
Transplant and the frozen heart
The December 23rd operation had been arranged with an organ from Bolzano, where the removal had taken place. During the transfer to Naples, the heart was accidentally frozen, compromising its function. Despite this, the organ was implanted in Domenico al Monaldi.
The investigative hypothesis is that the organ's deterioration and the timing of the transplant contributed to the child's fatal outcome. The Naples Prosecutor's Office has opened a manslaughter case against seven suspects, including the heart surgeon who performed the transplant, Guido Oppido, head of the Pediatric Cardiac Surgery and Transplant Unit at the Monaldi Hospital.
The recorded conversation
Another piece of information being examined by investigators is a conversation between the doctor and the child's mother, Patrizia, recorded by the woman. According to attorney Petruzzi, the heart surgeon explained that he had declared the child eligible for a transplant the day before "out of desperation," while the Heart Team subsequently deemed Domenico no longer suitable for the transplant.
"When the mother asked why they had been told the child was eligible for a transplant," the lawyer reports, "Oppido replied that he had said so out of desperation." This statement, if confirmed, would raise questions about the clinical evaluation and informed consent.
Documents and responsibilities
The CEC card, initially reported as missing by the defense and later identified in the medical records, is now a key point in the technical investigation. The Monaldi management has expressed full cooperation with the family, while the Prosecutor's Office is awaiting the expert reports to clarify the timing, condition of the organ, and surgical decisions.
The key issue remains the timeline: whether the child's heart was removed before the donated organ arrived, and whether the organ was already compromised. These two issues, according to the prosecution, could constitute medical negligence in the death of little Domenico.
Source EDITORIAL TEAM
Comments (1)
I don't quite understand the sequence. It seems the timing is wrong and the documents are unclear. The family is seeking answers, but the documents, from what I've read, raise doubts and create confusion. The doctor said different things, the experts disagree, and the truth remains uncertain. I hope clarity is forthcoming and justice is served.